CSK’s Proposal to Retain MS Dhoni as an Uncapped Player Sparks IPL Debate

The Chennai Super Kings (CSK) have proposed a rule change aimed at retaining their iconic player, MS Dhoni, as an uncapped player for the 2025 season. This suggestion, tabled at a recent meeting in Mumbai between the IPL committee and the ten franchises, has raised questions about player valuation and the league’s fairness.

Since its inception in 2008, the IPL has evolved to maintain a competitive balance through a series of rule changes. One such rule, scrapped in 2021 at the request of several teams, allowed players retired from international cricket for five or more years to be classified as uncapped. CSK has now proposed the reinstatement of this rule, hoping to retain Dhoni, who retired from international cricket on August 15, 2020, under more favourable financial terms.

The proposed change could potentially allow CSK to retain Dhoni for the 2025 season at a significantly reduced price compared to his current retention cost of INR 12 crore. This cost reduction could free up funds for CSK to invest in other players.

The proposal, however, has not been met with universal approval. Several franchises expressed concerns about the implications of such a change. Kavya Maran, owner of Sunrisers Hyderabad, voiced a strong objection, arguing, “Classifying retired internationals as uncapped players disrespects their value and sets a wrong precedent.” 

Maran and other franchise representatives believe that allowing the market to dictate a player’s worth through the auction process is a more equitable approach.

The debate highlights the tension between maintaining competitive balance and acknowledging the historical significance and value of veteran players like Dhoni. As one of the most celebrated players in IPL history, Dhoni’s retention has become a focal point in discussions about how to best structure team rosters and financial allocations.

In addition to CSK’s proposal, the meeting also considered a related issue concerning retired Indian players. Franchises reached a consensus on allowing Indian players who haven’t represented the national team in five years to lower their base price at auctions. This adjustment aims to create more opportunities for domestic players to re-enter the league.

This agreement shows the franchises’ collective interest in balancing opportunities for emerging talent with the inclusion of seasoned players. However, the proposal to classify retired internationals as uncapped remains contentious, with several teams worried about the potential impact on the integrity and competitiveness of the league.